本好きの下剋上 領主の養女

A tad rushed, but overall a really good episode. I loved the small smirk Ferdinand has right before quoting Veronica to Sylvester Some interactions were lost, like Monica praising Rozemyne after Wilfried says she's lucky she gets to eat cookies or him feeling bad that he left almost no cookies for his guard knight to eat, but not much more was lost in adaptation in Wilfried's pov. Rozemyne's pov was almost completely cut, but it makes sense that they cut it, considering that most of it is her discussing Wilfried's learning environment and schedule going forward. Another thing I think is a shame was lost in the adaptation was Ferdinand's words towards Wilfried. He didn't just say "I will crush you", he said "I will raise your siblings so that they take the Archduke position from you", which I find to be far more powerful

Keep in mind they have to condense the story to an extend. The anime adaptation rarely ever sits still because they want to cover as much as possible. In case of Ferdinant storming in, they probably changed that to easily fit it in with Rosemyne talking him down which just saves some time. You can argue about whether they priotize the right things to cut or mix together, but it kind of has to happen or the story moves too slowly for the anime production

I don´t think that the main issue is that they needed to cut things. The story is mainly about people talking but they do very little visually or even by audio to differentiate between a mundane discussion or a massive turning point. Imagine if you remove all the interesting shots and music from Death Note for example. Even if the dialogue would remaine the same it would still turn into a confused more boring story with little direction on what is actually supposed to be important. As an aside it also feels like how they decide to cut things isn´t that great either. More of a "lets tell the same story but leave import parts out" instead of a "lets focuse on the more important plot points and remove the non essential stuff for time". It feels like so many scenes jump around or just happen out of nowhere with very little setup that I would have been lost as a anime only watcher if I hadn´t read the LN.

S3 had moments where they straight up mis-represented Myne's emotions. The discussion about being adopted by Karstedt stands out in this regard. Rozemyne is suppressing her emotions during season 4. She wants nothing more than to hug her mother when she meets her, but has to put on the noble facade for the magic contract. Although I wish there was a bigger voice crack when she asked if it looked good.

[P5V12] ​I am not sure how they want to handle her marriage then. She needs another ADC even as an interim aub but it's hard to find someone willing to marry one. Lower ranked duchy candidates are probably out ot the running as she uses RM's compression method. And not sure how many high ranking ADCs are willing to marry her and then get demoted years down the line, when Melchior is old enough to take over. And Ehrenfest will probably some of its attractiveness for marriage the more Rm gets her projects in Alexandria up and running.

They're rushing too much. All the good emotional moments aren't landing. Last episode barely touched on Rozemyne's despair. In this episode, Ferdinand's threat of raising one of Wilfried's siblings to destroy him should have incited a kind of fear that he had never experienced or even thought possible before. Even Sylvester freezing at Florencia's recrimination looked more like courtesy between them. These moments are barely passed through in the rush to display all the important events like bullet points in a list. It's a shame because anime-only viewers aren't getting the kind of experience that gets them interested, like the previous seasons did for me. Something's been lost in the transition to the new studio.

از وقتی که فردیناند در داستان و این فصل ظاهر شد، دارند او را در نور تصویر می‌کنند و قابل درک است که اگر قرار بود خود واقعی‌اش را در سریال نشان دهند، این همه محبوبیت را از دست می‌داد، اما لعنت به این قسمت، من واقعاً به فردیناند خشمگین که اعلام می‌کرد ویلفرد را از ارث محروم می‌کند، نیاز داشتم. آنها همچنین دارند ماین را به یک قدیس خسته‌کننده تبدیل می‌کنند و هاله‌ی زنده و کودکانه‌ی او را از بین می‌برند، در ابتدا به نظر تصادفی می‌آمد اما واقعاً حس می‌شود که دیالوگ‌های او فقط باید دیالوگ‌های خوب و معصومانه‌ی خودش باشند، و به این ترتیب یک قدیس ایسکای خسته‌کننده‌ی دیگر خلق می‌کنند، من تعجب می‌کنم که آیا سایر قدیسان ایسکای نیز در منبع اصلی خود شخصیت خاص خود را دارند و اقتباس انیمه‌ای آنها از آنها صرف نظر کرده است؟ for a moment Florancia really was great and shone beneath the silent smile but it was just a moment and just a moment I thought she needed to be more shocked...

Definitely the mood , story telling and direction are not simply good and again lots of cuts + I think and it's only my opinion but unlike the source material this 4 seasons feel like kids show to me and this season feels too rushed, however this ep and ep6 felt better in my opinion plus I don't think we can expect more ... did they have enough budget this season I wonder ... however the voice acting is incredible like always and graphics and colors are way way better than last 3 seasons

It feels like they're limiting even the voice acting's directing for the sake of less/faster animation. Haven't read the manga; but, iirc, Ferdinand and Ridhyarda are, at times literally, shouting down Sylvester's excuses. That naked fury juxtaposed with Florencia's quiet, long-incubated anger/despair define that scene to me. I get that Ferdinand finding out about the conversation, inviting himself late, and flying into the room to demand Wilfried's disinheritance could be seen as bloat for the runtime/animation. However, the same VA conveyed the character's rage much better during the Trombe hunt than here and I can't see a reason besides the abrupt cut to the group settled into a very static post-meal tea. Even the low quality animation of Ferdinand pointing towards Myne's temporary guards gave the VA/director/audience a visual queue that allowed the change of his tone/volume to feel more natural.

First of all let me preface this by admitting I love this chapter in the books and so there may be some biases. However, this episode just seemed to have butchered the feeling of this moment. It feels too calm, yet too rushed. You almost could've cut Rosemyne from the episode without changing much. And the dinner scene seemed to have muted Florencia's quiet rage against Sylvester to being non-existent. (At least compared to how I read it in the book and saw it in the episode.)

Yeah this episode was so disappointing. Ferdinand should be heart-stoppingly terrifying, but it barely lands. I honestly can't remember a time when Ferdinand displayed such massive emotions earlier than this. There are some under currents and a few places where he gets angry but not like this. His anger in other scenes mostly happens off screen because he's still not very open with rozemyne before her adoption. Florencia too and Rhyardia. Its rare for nobles to get so openly emotional so it was very clear how insane the problem was. I also feel like rozemyne's vindictiveness when she made the suggestion was barely there. She was just so done with Wilfied's bs in the novel. Ugh... I was really looking forward to this episode too...

Overall a good episode, but this adaptation lacks the “Oomph” factor. I can understand certain things being cut due to time constraints, but I cannot when it comes to making characters’ expressions match their tone, especially when the seiyuu‘s acting is stellar. I feel that they could have done a much better job with Rhiyarda, Ferdinand and Florencia’s expressions in certain scenes. The chibi segment was very cute, it gets my seal of approval.

the episode was decent, but without all the internal monologue and extra details from the Light Novel i can't help but feel only whelmed. like others pointed out. i really miss the scene where Silvester asks them if she learned to be so evil from Ferdinand. in the end im still happy about the anime though. this really makes me wanna see the Royal Academy animated, with more action and evil Plots. but im pretty sure we gonna see Charlottes trouble soon. it comes this season, right?

Finally the awaited episode is here! Right off the bat, Lessy is adorable as always. Oof, getting shown up by orphans and commoners must have been fun, Wilfried. Aww, young Sylvester and Ferdinand are adorable. Florencia's anger seems... subdued. Like she's a noble so of course she's able to maintain her composure, but given how is this also a visual adaptation, I think they could have done a better job to show how much she's actually seething inside. And here lies my obligatory Veronica sucks. THE CHIBIS ARE ADORABLE! Monika finally speaks! Pfft, poor Fey. I wonder how he's doing, hahahaha. And Nicola's pout is so cute. Compared to other episodes, this episode seems to be a better adaptation of the light novel, but things are still flat and rushed. I can't tell if it's because they don't want to put as much care into Bookworm in general, or if it's because it's just Part 3. I will be so sad if Part 4 and Part 5 are adapted in a way that succeeds my expectations while Part 3 is given this treatment.