本好きの下剋上 領主の養女

Hm, they did it again... They removed another scene of Rozemyne overstepping her authority and threatening someone for no reason. The scene where she "offers" the soldiers to join the monastery after they complained that the orphans were living better lives than them was just gone from this I'm not a fan of them defanging the story so much, especially because it's important characterization for our main character Other than that the episode was quite good. Great even

I think the characterization for Myne in the anime has been quite different from that in the novels from the first season, her behaviour is often softened. I get why, as Myne at the beginning of the story is not exactly a likable character, but that also reduces her development and now sometimes I find she is way too perfect for the gremlin she actually is. It's like the version of the anime is the saint version of her that Hartmut makes propaganda of.

Hi I think you misunderstood my comment. I was referring to the sleeping in the dining hall scene. I was saying the anime omitted much of the following scene, basically the whole resolution to the conflict "Boys are forbidden from entering the girls building; they are only allowed to go to the dining room. You would normally not be allowed in here, but we brought you here today so that you could see for yourselves that the girls are being treated equally." "I know, but that is irrelevant. This is the girls' building. Even their male family members cannot enter,"' "To other gray shrine maidens, Thore and Rick are not family- they are strangers and men like any other. Just as you wish to protect Nora, Thore, I wish to protect my gray shrine maidens." "If you insist on staying together, you will need to sleep in the corner of the dining hall." "I will only be lending you space to sleep; the dining hall can be entered by all, so other men have free access to the space as well. It is not your personal area, and others will not be forbidden from entering your sleeping space." "You can sleep in the dining hall if you absolutely insist. but I think that Nora and Marthe would rest easier in the girls' building where men are forbidden from going than in the dining hall where anybody can enter. Am I right?" "Thore, please go to the boys' building. We'll sleep in the girls' building." "I don't want to sleep in the dining hall. I won't be able to relax with men I don't know walking around. It's been so long since I've been able to sleep easy... Please understand, Thore"

I don't think she overstepped her authority in that scene. It's not a good idea to let that kind of resentful atmosphere fester among the soldiers when they're supposed to guard and protect the gray priests & shrine maidens, whom as orphans (technically) have the lowest position in Yurgenschmidtt. If it escalates they could even be harmed and even if not, they can be still be hurt by their words. Especially since Myne has the experience of being guarded by someone who hates her and who has a higher position than her, and we all know how it went down.

Of course, but from the perspective of everyone else she's a volatile noble around whom you don't know what you're allowed to say. "What do you mean we can't talk shit about orphans? They're orphans for crying out loud!" is probably something that at least one person in Rozemyne's presence has thought. She's seemingly prioritizing the wrong people and lashing out at improper times She did the same in the novels with Egmont, the blue priest that messed up the book room. During her initiation ceremony she crushes him a little, for which Ferdinand scolds her, saying that he hadn't done anything to her yet, and that, as there had been a change in power, he should've been allowed some time to prove where his loyalty is

The hasse adaptation itself is ok probably 5/10 and 6/10 after the Fran scene, I wish its as good as the manga which I put at 9/10 but the extra scene of mayor being terrified is nice touch. The budget is gone except for a few shot for hasse and event that lead to hasse got skipped and by a lot (7 chapter for 1 episode). The first half is rushed as hell and the cut content create massive tonal shift from the first half to second half. The vibe is off, people like to say that part 3 manga adaptation is horrible but scene/panel direction in that adaptation is amazing only the artstyle. Any scene that paints rozemyne in bad light and not in major scene will be skipped. The animation and pacing seems rebounds back next episode and probably the end of hasse subplot will be as good as concert and end the cour in winter.

If you look at the episode count, you need to same time and money for the end of the volume. Remember we are also owed a scene from the first volume that just can't be skipped. It's not a matter of bad light or good light, but just lining up with themes, making the episode cohesive. This episode couldn't have been more cohesive, as it's connecting through the theme of separation and Myne's knowledge of what it is to be an uneducated commoner. It's all moved about to fit, and this isn't re:zero, which cuts its own intro and ending song half the time to get more things on screen.

7 chapters? I counted: - P3V2 prologue - Discussing the Harvest Festval, with a plot line left for later [P3V2] the jureve . - The new orphans - The first page of the next chapter as a post credit scene. Some details are left aside, like Brigitte or Fran discovering the highbeast, the option if sleeping in the dining hall but ocerall I think the content had been well covered. For Hasse arc, [P3] we will probably have 2 more episodes next one and one in Spring.

Trying to rush to fit all of part 3 into this season is harming the product haha There ofc are gonna be cuts for a LN adaptation, its not often we get a 1:1(Apothecary was dope with its adaptation!), but yeah. Much of the connective tissue is missing and you're just left with the show going from scene to scene to scene. It feels like we aren't in one scene long enough and then it shifts to the next one Overall it's a fine episode, don't let my complaints drag that down. This section of the story is one I often see people speak about so naturally I'm gonna be negative if I know it can be better

The contrast between Rozemyne, who cannot see her family, and her family in the slums, and the bond between Hasse’s orphans—who have not been separated from their sibilings—was heartbreaking. The scene where they reunited with Effa, exchanging only a few words, was also well done. What worries me is that this episode has so many omissions; I'm concerned that anime-only viewers might misunderstand Rozemyne as a typical selfish noble.

We're officially starting the second volume of Part 3. As always, Damuel is the best! Look at him encouraging Effa. And I really do like how we get to see so many hairpins for Rozemyne. HA! I can't get over how Kamil looks when Gunther is hiding under the blanket. Your father is doing his best! Is this the first time we've heard Nicola talk the entire series? Yay! And we love Fran as always. Pfft, we've replaced the chibis this episode with a lecture. Now that the harspiel concert is over, it seems we're back to rushing through scenes, and it's honestly such a shame. I feel like some scenes don't have the impact they should have.

The contract explicitly states that they "cannot treat eachother as family; they must treat her as the noble Rozemyne". They can speak without worry for mess-ups regarding ettiquete in the secret room, but the contract is still in effect. Gunther, Effa, Tuuli, and Kamil must maintain the emotional distance expected of commoner associates to a noble. Lutz gets around this and becomes the hug battery because he was not made to sign that contract.

She would need a reason to summon her to the temple in the first place. A noble can’t just summon a random commoner. Lutz and Tuuli already have business relationships with Rozemyne. The scene between them happens in the hidden room, where Rozemyne can drop the facade somewhat, but Damuel is still a noble and wants/needs her to keep up appearances for everyone’s sake. They can show more emotion but can’t really speak, especially because Effa doesn’t yet know proper noble decorum.

New plot starts which I assume means it's vol 2 now. Gunther and Effa are a joy to see. I'm very happy mama gets to use Tuuli's excuse to see Myne. I was so worried Gunther will break character or that the other guards will recognize Myne... New hungry&angry kids, yay. I would've thought all kids would go with Myne, but street smart ones that are not completely desperate, WOULD be careful around new people so that checks. It's unpleasant to see them take it out on Myne. Why does Myne even have to be the one teaching them things? Leave it to Fran/Gil? Poor Fran had to get violence here. Really reminds me of how Lutz started beating the shit out of Gil in a similar situation and Fran was all alarmed and innocent boy.

I was so worried Gunther will break character or that the other guards will recognize Myne... Basically no guards ever saw her. The only one who really did was Otto, and he knows to shut the hell up. Even the ones who did see her wouldn't put it together though, and the reason is that you just simply wouldn't expect it to be her, especially when she speaks and acts in an entirely different way. Keep in mind that Gunther very publicly had a funeral for her, so even if a guard thinks for just a second that it might be her, he will remember that she died, and just think "huh that's weird". In the novels we're told that even her family struggled to recognise her from a distance because she just felt different. It's unpleasant to see them take it out on Myne. Why does Myne even have to be the one teaching them things? Leave it to Fran/Gil? She's the one in charge of the orphanage, so she took it upon herself to explain how it works because she likely feels responsible for them. It would probably fall to Wilma in the main temple, but there isn't really an alternative to her there yet

I'm kind of baffaled by the scene with the mayor (plus another reason to check out LN, Dragon-Gods help me with that deep dive). Another example of nobility just YOLO-facerolling the situation with no concerns of everybody else's position and circumstances. If only Ferdinand and Myne were to question/interrogate the mayor about the kids and his reluctance and then hush it out with the noble that wanted to purchase them, the whole thing could be dissolved much more amicably... Although, if there is any sort of cut content from LN that complicates situation even further, I'd be glad to hear it out. But as it is - a lesson in clever political maneuver would be of more value than lesson in ruthlessness. Especially if Yurgenschmitd wants to grow as a nation.

Spoilers for what I assume will be next week's episode: Yes, this is a problem that Rozemyne and Ferdinand have made for themselves. The mayor selling the orphans is evidently the responsible thing for him to do, thus right now they are the villains. Ferdinand will acknowledge this, and thus work to amend this after scolding Rozemyne on her actions. Rozemyne basically stole another noble's property by abusing her authority, putting Hasse as a whole in a precarious situation. Ferdinand will use Hasse as a learning opportunity for her, making her create an opposing faction to the mayor to replace him(Because he committed the crime of blatantly rebelling against the archduke's adopted daughter's orders by not bringing out every orphan he had)

I know as much, but thank you nonetheless. Though, I would say that Myne is more of a fall girl who, really, didn't knew any better (those are still her babysteps of handling business as a noble, after all). The real effjobs are Sylvester and Frrdinand - right at the conclusion of the test meal at the restaurant. They could very well take the situation and work it out with Myne piece by piece in a teaching-learning manner instead of zooming out to build the damn temple like their crotches were on fire. And while it's more or less in Sylv's character (and another reason to give him a boot to the head)... where the sweet mother Asha was Ferdinand's shit-o-meter and leash to tug his brother with?