2026-04-24
記事URLをコピー
+2429

SkeettheVandelBuster
Carrot. She was funny, had good rapport with the crew, could more than hold her own in fights, had a neat design, had a job as lookout in the crow’s nest, added another woman alongside Nami and Robin, and brought representation for the Mink race
キャロットだな。面白くて、仲間との相性も良くて、戦闘でも十分やれて、デザインも良くて、見張り台で見張り役をやってて、ナミとロビンに加えて女性メンバーが増えて、ミンク族の代表にもなる。+891
JLaboss65
Pedro dying felt like a tragic back story playing out in real time too. I was utterly convinced up until the raid
ペドロの死は、悲劇的な過去がリアルタイムで進行してるようにも感じたよ。襲撃までは完全に確信してた。+266
blahmaster6000
But on the bright side, the raid can still fail!
でも明るい面としては、襲撃はまだ失敗する可能性があるぜ!+34
King3D
Oh yeah I remember that shit. And the whole "there's gonna be another timeskip because the crew can't beat a Yonko yet." as if this is Hunter X Hunter.
ああ、あのクソみたいなの覚えてるわ。「麦わらの一味はまだ四皇に勝てないから、もう一回タイムスリップがある」ってやつ。まるでハンターハンターみたいに言ってたな。+16
snakebit1995
原文
Carrot was checking all the flags until Yamato showed up and kinda just stole her spot in the story
Carrot was in "Crew shots" when Jinbie showed up and everything and then suddenly she just vanishes from the story and a new girl who's naive about the world and social norms but has big dreams of exploring shows up...
It's hard not to convince me Yamato kinda co-opted Carrot's role in the latter half of Wano, as soon as Yamato shows up Carrot just vanishes and her story is rushed to an ending that makes no sense for what was set up for her with leaving Zou and her father figure literally dying and telling her to go out and see the world...so why is her story resolution that she needs to go home and babysit while her cool uncles take a vacation
Oda is a good writer but Carrot's character arc is really sloppily done and her place in the story super inconsistent.
キャロットは全てのフラグを立てていたのに、ヤマトが現れて彼女のストーリー上のポジションをかっさらっていったようなものだ。ジンベエが登場して「クルーショット」にキャロットがいたのに、突然物語から消えて、世界や社会常識に疎いけど大きな夢を持つ新キャラが現れた。+26
Glassberg
It was so weird that she left. Especially considering her friendship with Chopper, she just suddenly up and leaves to run Zou.
Then again, like Yamato and Vivi, that now makes 3 former/Honorary Straw Hats running a kingdom that could aid Luffy at the end.
キャロットが抜けるのは本当に変だった。特にチョッパーとの友情を考えると、突然ゾウに戻って統治しろって。でも考えてみれば、ヤマトやビビと同様に、ルフィを最終決戦で支援できる国を治める元・名誉麦わらの一味が3人になったとも言える。+145
Consistentdegeneracy
The reason she left was even dumber. Like, be honest. Does Carrot strike you as the leader type? Wanda is right there.
抜ける理由もさらにアホらしかった。正直に言って、キャロットがリーダー気質に見えるか? ワンダが適任だろ。+86
SkeettheVandelBuster
Yeah the teenage rabbit who snuck away to go be a pirate is supposed to lead a country because she was secretly a duchess (asspull) and it was also what her hero (who also snuck away to be a pirate because he was inspired by Roger) wanted? Totally weird and nonsensical but it sets up a triumphant return of carrot leading the minks into battle to help Luffy alongside all the other allies
そうそう、こっそり抜け出して海賊になった10代のウサギが、実は公爵令嬢だった(後付け設定)からって国を治めるべきで、憧れの人物(ロジャーに影響されて同じくこっそり海賊になった)もそう望んでいたって? 完全に変で無意味だけど、劇的な再登場への布石だな。+34
SkeettheVandelBuster
Don’t forget Momo, who is literally the shogun of Wano. Yamato is just there to help keep things in order. All of them feel like such fake-outs but Vivi set the precedent for “I can’t join the crew cuz I have actual responsibilities here” which was the same excuse Sanji, Chopper, and Franky all tried to use until their people were like “nah you can leave”
モモの助も忘れるなよ。文字通りワノ国の将軍だ。ヤマトはただ秩序維持のためにいる。全員がフェイクアウトっぽいけど、ビビが「ここに責任があるから仲間になれない」という前例を作った。サンジ、チョッパー、フランキーも同じ言い訳をしようとしたんだ。+65
Glassberg
I forgot about Momo. Luffy is double dipping on Wano loyalty.
モモの助を忘れてた。ルフィはワノ国から二重に忠誠を得てるな。+25
kroqeteer
原文
i think it was good for vivi. The thing with sanji and chopper is that the people around them could see that they couldn't live their dreams where they were. Sanji can't find the all blue from the restaurant, and chopper cant cure the world's diseases from an island that won't accept him. Vivi was different because her dream was to go back home, to create peace for her people. That's why the end of alabasta is her making the announcement the way she does, she loves the straw hats and loves traveling with them but that isn't her dream. her dream is to care for her people
i think the problem with yamato and carrot is that its so sudden, all yamato talks about is how she wants to go travel the world like oden and then suddenly she changes her mind. Carrot wants to be a pirate like the people she looks up to, then suddenly she's a duke. narratively they feel jarring in ways that previous characters don't because those characters all felt like they had planned arcs
ビビに関しては良かったと思う。サンジとチョッパーの場合、周りの人間は彼らがその場所では夢を叶えられないと見抜いていた。サンジはレストランではオールブルーを見つけられないし、チョッパーは自分を受け入れない島では世界の病気を治せない。ビビは違った。+18
mudi121
Carrot, yamato, and I’m praying Loki joins the crew cause he’s op and a good addition to the crew
キャロット、ヤマト、そして俺はロキが仲間になるのを祈ってる。強すぎるし、一味に良い追加になる。+66
Maximillion322
原文
Idk I genuinely don’t think Carrot has all that much going on story or personality wise. I think people just like her design.
Yamato is enough of a weirdo with enough of a backstory to theoretically fit the crew but he was also just really shoehorned into the end of wano, it would have been nice to at least get a little setup with him or maybe have him involved in the story beyond showing up near the end of the raid just to exposition dump
Loki seems the most fitting to me mainly because he got his own entire backstory flashback sequence that just feels like the way Oda likes to treat strawhats but it’s also SO late in the game to be adding new main crewmembers at this point, I think he’d be better as an ally not to mention the logistical issues of him being way to big to get on the Sunny, but also too small to walk through the ocean like Sanjuan Wolf
いや、キャロットにはストーリー的にも性格的にも大した要素がないと思う。みんなデザインが好きなだけだろ。ヤマトは変人で背景も十分にあるから理論上は一味に合うけど、ワノ国終盤に無理やりねじ込まれた感じがする。+43
Ok_Cranberry_3013
原文
I don't think Loki being too big and not fitting in the Sunny is that much of an issue. The Sunny is made out of Adam wood, which is native to Elbaph. Franky could easily expand the ship to make it bigger and accommodate Loki, and narratively, it would make sense too.
Beyond being just an emotional gut punch, replacing Merry also marks an important cornerstone to the crews infamy. The merry was small and cozy, fit for a small-time pirate crew who hadn't made their mark yet, but the Sunny is bigger, stronger, an improvement to Merry, which is perfect for a pirate crew who is beginning to make their marks to the world (+ had also grown in members.)
So Sunny being expanded, making it much bigger, maybe even the size of Whitebeard's Moby Dick, makes thematical sense as the crew is now an Emperor crew, showing how they are at the top of the world now and are known worldwide.
ロキが大きすぎてサニー号に入らないのは問題じゃないと思う。サニー号はエルバフ原産のアダムの木でできている。フランキーなら簡単に船を拡張してロキに対応できるし、物語的にも理にかなっている。感情的な面だけでなく…+20
tonyt0nychopper
See, I never saw the whole carrot joining-thing… I might be the only one. She felt more like a Vivi (even though I consider Vivi a SH) here for a time, and then gone the next…
俺はキャロット加入説を一度も信じなかった。唯一かもしれない。彼女はビビ(ビビは麦わらの一味だと思ってるけど)のように一時的にいて、すぐに去っていく感じだった。+16
Rjm0007
Bon clay if he made it out of impel down
ボン・クレー(Mr.2)だな。インペルダウンから脱出できてたら。+474
Strangely-Chewy
Keep hoping bon clay will reappear at some point. Need more "straw boy" in my daily!
いつかボン・クレーが再登場するのを願い続けてる。「ストローボーイ」をもっと日常に!+158
Handerborte
Bon Clay took over after Invankov in Impel Down. He is the new queen of Newkama land
ボン・クレーはインペルダウンでイワンコフの後を継いだ。ニューカマーランドの新しい女王だ。+48
serlibob
I think bon clay will escape impel down one day, and when we least expect it, he will change his face to help luffy with a big smile. Then luffy will change to the gear five to save bon clay later. And they will dance in a feast together 👌🏻
ボン・クレーはいつかインペルダウンを脱出して、予想外のタイミングで顔を変えてルフィを助けに来ると思う。そしてルフィは後でボン・クレーを救うためにギア5になる。一緒に宴で踊るんだ。+22
caparisme

Zombie tree and zombie unicorn back at thriller bark. Such a shame they're loyal to Moria they'd make great nakamas
スリラーバークのゾンビの木とゾンビのユニコーンだ。モリアに忠誠を誓ってるのが残念。良い仲間になったのに。+330
Malik-Almuhawsin
They’ll pull up during final war trust
最終決戦で現れるさ。信じろ。+75
caparisme
I believe.
俺は信じる。+17
Co-met
South bird. I know lufy wouldnt cage it but just looks so convenient
サウスバードだな。ルフィは檻に入れないけど、すごく便利そうだ。+185
Raisineer
Condoriano. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
コンドリアーノ。🤣🤣🤣🤣+163
Leather_Crazy_5950
An outrage. That man should have stayed with the crew! 😂
ありえないだろ。あの男は仲間として残るべきだったのに!w+36
vivvav
Condoriano IS a member of the crew, tf you talkin about
コンドリアーノはもう仲間だろ、何言ってんだお前+16
GenGaara25
原文
I've never understood this one, but I hear it a lot. When we met Paulie my reaction was "Yeah, this isn't him." He felt too normal for the Strawhats, he was just some guy, but the strawhats are exclusively made up of weirdos. And the fact that he was presented so obviously felt like such a red herring.
Then Franky showed up, and the moment we saw he was also a shipwright it was "Yup, that's our guy, a fucking weirdo who can mend ships, thats the new crewmate 100%"
これだけは今まで一度も理解できなかったけど、よく聞くんだよな。パウリーと出会った時の俺の反応は「いや、こいつじゃない」だった。麦わらの一味にしては普通すぎる、ただの一般人って感じでさ。でも麦わらの一味って変人しかいないだろ。しかもあんなに露骨に仲間っぽく描かれてるから、完全にミスリードだと思ったよ+135
The_Eternal_Wayfarer
原文
He was male!Vivi with the prudery gimmick. Similar combat style too. I too immediately said “yeah, that’s him” as soon as Franky showed up.
Notice also that Franky does not destroy ships. He *dismantles* them and sells the parts on the black market. In order to dismantle a ship and save enough parts and in good enough conditions to sell them, you need first and foremost a very solid knowledge of how ships are built.
あいつは貞操観念ネタを持った男版ビビだったな。戦闘スタイルも似てたし。フランキーが出てきた瞬間、俺も即座に「あ、こいつだ」って思ったよ。
ついでに言うと、フランキーは船を破壊しない。彼は船を*解体*して、その部品を闇市場で売ってるんだ。船を解体して十分な部品を確保するためには…+26
Odd_Potato3019
Carrot. She jived really well with the crew, could hold her own in a fight better than Nami or Usopp, and fulfilled a necessary function on the crew as the lookout.I feel like her going back to rule Zou came out of nowhere and didn’t feel earned.
キャロット。彼女は一味とすごく相性が良くて、戦闘でもナミやウソップより互角以上に戦えたし、見張り役として必要な機能を果たしてた。ゾウに戻って統治するって展開は急に出てきた感じがして、納得できなかったな。+116
Sendhentaiandyiff
It pisses me off so much that Carrot just got assaulted and demeaned by Perospero and then that's just the end of her arc.
キャロットがペロスペローに襲われて辱められて、それで彼女の物語が終わりってのが本当に腹立つ。+25
Odd_Potato3019
I have the feeling that she was meant to join, but then Oda changed his mind because he needed a familiar character to lead Zou into the final battle to back up Luffy. It’s the exact same role that Vivi, Rebecca, Katakuri, Marco, Iceburg, Shirahoshi, Momo, and Loki will all fulfill.
最初は彼女が仲間になる予定だったけど、尾田が考えを変えたんじゃないかな。最終決戦でルフィを支援するためにゾウを率いる、おなじみのキャラクターが必要だったんだろう。ビビ、レベッカ、カタクリ、マルコ、アイスバーグ、しらほし、モモ、そしてロキがみんな果たすのと同じ役割だよ。+20
Sendhentaiandyiff
WANDA! She's right there! She makes way more sense as a duchess/leader!
ワンダだろ!あそこにいるじゃん!彼女の方が公爵/リーダーとしてずっと筋が通ってる!+21
Oreo-and-Fly
Yea. Imo i wouldve wanted her and Zoro to train together. Zoro is about strength and thats her fighting style too.
They would be close at the crow's nest and it would go a long way for Zoro to train a female fighter to be strong, proving his master wrong and honouring Kuina that way
そうだな。俺は彼女とゾロが一緒に修行する展開が見たかった。ゾロは力が全てだし、それが彼女の戦闘スタイルでもあるからな。
二人は檣楼で仲良くなって、ゾロが女性戦士を鍛えて強くすることで、師匠の考えが間違ってたことを証明し、くいなに敬意を表すって展開になっただろうな。+19
No-Agent-9620

I thought a backstory, a goal and an inner conflict are solid ques. Wasn't the case. He was cool, Carrot too btw.
過去編、目標、内面の葛藤があれば確実だと思ったんだけどな。そうじゃなかった。あいつはカッコよかったけど、キャロットもな。+70
emigum
yeah oda was evil for teasing it up to the last chapter that she would join
ああ、尾田は最終話直前まで彼女が仲間になるって匂わせてたから、悪意しか感じないわ+22
mezonsen
Yamato being a self-insert for the fanbase who wanted to witness the One Piece itself convinced me he would join, and yet total rug-pull. Wacky
ヤマトがワンピースをこの目で見たいと思ってるファンの自己投影キャラだって確信してたから、仲間になると思ったのに、まさかのどんでん返し。クソすぎる+19
CompetitiveError2872
原文
Carrot and Yamato.
Yamato for obvious reasons. Still hoping to this day esp since Luffy approves.
For Carrot: I was part of the copers who thought Carrot snuck in a barrel aboard the Sunny. It all lined up perfectly too with the whole theme of inherited will with her carrying on Pedro's who wanted to go with Roger back then. But then Inuarashi and Nekomamushi quit their jobs and they made her into Zou's new leader and... yeah.
キャロットとヤマト。
ヤマトは言うまでもない。今でもルフィが認めてるからまだ期待してる。
キャロットについては、俺はサニー号の樽にこっそり潜り込んだ派の信者だった。ペドロの意志を継ぐっていうテーマとも完璧に合致してたしな…+59
TheUnsungMelody
原文
Everyone has said carrot and Yamato which I also agree with, but I 100% thought Vivi was going to travel with the straw hats. I say travel with, because I think we can all agree that she *is* a straw hat. She just had other important stuff to take care of.
I also thought Lilith would join the crew. That could still happen, but I think Oda is setting up for her to stay behind on Elbaph to build a new lab and help them bolster their tech/defenses against the world government. I don’t know if we’ll get any new additions to the crew this late in the game, but the most likely to me is Bonney. I could see Kuma dying on Elbaph and inspiring Bonney to join the straw hats with an important role to help fight Imu as an effective 2nd Nika. Loki is also a potential crew member, but I think (current manga spoilers) >!he’s more likely to remain on Elbaph as an Imu deterrent and dedicate the giant forces to the straw hats grand fleet for the final war.!<
みんなキャロットとヤマトって言ってるけど、それも同意するわ。でも俺は100%ビビが麦わらの一味と旅すると思ってた。旅するって言ったのは、彼女が*麦わらの一味の一員*だってことは誰もが同意すると思うからな。ただ彼女には他に大事な用事があったってだけだ。
あとリリスも仲間になると思ってた+28
ExactFun
I genuinely thought Sogeking would join. He would have been a good mentor character for Ussop and the others.
俺はマジでそげキングが仲間になると思ってたよ。ウソップや他の連中にとって良い師匠キャラになっただろうにな。+27
meowmeowcomputation
Call me delulu but I always thought Oda was trying to telegraph Egg McBig coming out of retirement to join
妄想って言われてもいいけど、俺はずっと尾田がエッグマックビッグの復帰加入を匂わせてると思ってた+25
G00nie_Bagz
Waiper. I'm still butthurt to this day that Waiper didn't join the Strawhats.
ワイパー。今でもワイパーが麦わらの一味に入らなかったのが悔しくてたまらない。+16
Leather_Crazy_5950
To me, it wouldn't have made sense.
Especially because his sole goal was to bring his people back to their homeland. He never showed any interest beyond sailing the "sea beneath the clouds." Besides, he interacted very little with the crew (the fight with Luffy was comparable to a skirmish).
俺には意味が通らなかったな。
特に彼の唯一の目的は自分の民を故郷に連れ戻すことだったし。「雲の下の海」を航海することには全く興味を示さなかった。それに一味との交流もほとんどなかったしな(ルフィとの戦いは小競り合い程度だった)。+31
ByadKhal
原文
Monet
Pretty cool devil fruit, unique feature with her being harpy and an overall fun personality (aside from the kidnapping children part for Caesar).
I imagined her being similar to Robin as in being forced to join Doffy due to having no other choice and maybe help the crew in a similar fashion as Vivi back then.
Also, back then in Alabasta, I really thought Bon Clay would join the crew eventually as he had awesome chemistry with them, a Solid Devil Fruit and a cool fighting style.
モネ
かなりクールな悪魔の実、ハーピーというユニークな特徴、そして全体的に楽しい性格(シーザーのために子供を誘拐してた部分は除く)。
ドフィに強制的に従わされてたロビンみたいな感じで、同じように一味を助ける展開になると思ってたよ。+19
原文
原文
原文
原文